Should Kids Have Cell Phones? Experts Pick Sides
9:24 AMPosted by: John S Kiernan
Becoming too connected used to be an issue kids had with stuffed animals and pacifiers. Now it’s a matter of smart phones and tablets. And whether this is a positive development remains to be seen.
Sure, growing up in the technology age has its fair share of benefits: instant access to endless educational possibilities and preparation for the jobs of the future, just to name a couple. But it also exposes young people to a host of issues far less benign than anything even the Velveteen Rabbit could throw at you. From radiation exposure and childhood obesity to cyberbullying and sex crimes, kids these days must run a gauntlet of technological issues in order to get into a good college, earn a decent wage and ultimately lead a happy, healthy, prosperous life.
Among the important decisions parents must therefore make – along with screen-time limits and whether to monitor social media – is when to give a child his or her own cell phone. Is there an ideal age? What parental rules and restrictions should accompany the privilege? And, perhaps most importantly, should phones be allowed at school?
Researchers from the London School of Economics found that students in high schools with cell-phone bans received about a week’s worth of additional education each year and scored over 6% better on standardized tests. But how far can we extrapolate such findings, both in terms of younger children and beyond school grounds?
For additional insight that may help guide parents, we posed one simple question – “should kids have cell phones?” – to a panel of leading experts in the fields of education, family studies and technology. You can check out their bios and responses below. And if you’d like to join the discussion, you can share your thoughts in the comments section at the end of the page.
Why Kids Should Not Have Cell PhonesHighlights:
- "Infants, toddlers and preschoolers should not have cell phones. The argument has a few simple points - cell phones are expensive, screen time is bad for kids this age, and the kids don’t know what to do with the phones."
Ross Hunter // Director, Washington State Department of Early Learning
- "There are several reasons why kids should not have cell phones. Kids with cell phones are likely to spend too much time on them, keeping them from doing more productive things like exercising and reading. There is increasing evidence of addiction to electronic devices, which like any other kind of addiction is destructive. Many kids with cell phones lose sleep because of talking at night or because of being anxious that they do not miss a call, and as a result suffer from headaches and sleepiness during the day, which interferes with learning at school."
David O. Carpenter // Director, Institute for Health and the Environment & Professor of Environmental Health Sciences, University at Albany
- "Kids should not have cell phones. I may be alone on this, but I don’t see a real need for them, and I certainly don’t see the benefits for young children. I actually know of a five-year-old child who owns a cell phone. Children’s excessive use of cell phones can lead to issues with both health and safety."
Georgia S. Thompson // Vice President of the Programs and Affiliate Network, National Black Child Development Institute
- "We go to great lengths to protect the child brain with car seats and bike helmets, yet we are exposing them now to an agent that many governments control/ban/restrict. Due to their thinner skulls and unique physiology, children can receive twice as much radiation into their brain and up to ten times as much into their skull compared at an adult. Children’s developing brains are the most vulnerable."
Theodora Scarato // Clinical Social Worker & Director of Public Affairs and Educational Programs, Environmental Health Trust
< >- Patti Agatston President of the International Bullying Prevention Association and Co-author of “Cyber Bullying: Bullying in the Digital Age”
- David O. Carpenter Director of the Institute for Health and the Environment and Professor of Environmental Health Sciences at the University at Albany
- Theodora Scarato & Devra Davis Clinical Social Worker and Director of Public Affairs and Educational Programs at Environmental Health Trust & President of the Environmental Health Trust, visiting Professor of Medicine at The Hebrew University
- Georgia S. Thompson Vice President of the Programs and Affiliate Network at National Black Child Development Institute
- Ross Hunter Director at Washington State Department of Early Learning
- Jerry Yang Executive Director at Kai Ming Head Start
- Toddlers and preschoolers chew on stuff. Strawberry jam gets into the micro-USB ports. Both turn out to be bad for expensive electronics. Who knew?
- The American Academy of Pediatricians suggests limiting screen time for kids age 2-5 to 1 hour a day of high quality programming only. There is no high quality programming available on cell phones. Really, there just isn’t. Little kids should play with blocks and other unstructured toys. For younger kids we’re back to the jam argument. See the Mayo Clinic’s site for more on this.
- Do you really want your three-year-old taking calls from people you don’t know or making international calls by accident?
Highlights:
- "As digital natives, many kids begin using technology at a very young age. Having a cell phone seems to be a natural extension of that. Does that mean a kindergarten student should have one? No. Does it mean it should be automatically ruled out? No. Rather than simply answering no or yes to a child having a cell phone, one must consider the purpose for having it. As kids and society become more technologically savvy, the answer will often be yes, a cell phone will be a benefit for the child."
Jan Urbanski – Director of Safe and Humane Schools in the Institute on Family & Neighborhood Life at Clemson University
- "I think age 9 is a good time for a cell phone—the student is in the 3rd or 4th grade and they are learning about the world. However, it is key for students to be given training around using a cell phone. For example, students should know about turning on/off the cell phone in school as well as lowering or muting the volume of the ringer during classes."
Beth Rosenberg // Director, Tech Kids Unlimited
- "The real issue is not a question of yes or not but instead one of how. In other words, what we should be focusing on is whether young people are using cell phones responsibly and judiciously and how well we are teaching them to do both."
Robert Crosnoe // Chair of the Department of Sociology, University of Texas at Austin & President-Elect, Society for Research on Adolescence
< >- Roberta Michnick Golinkoff Unidel H. Rodney Sharp Professor of Education, Psychology and Linguistics & Cognitive Science at the University of Delaware and Author of “Becoming Brilliant: What Science Tells us About Raising Successful Children”
- Robert Crosnoe Chair of the Department of Sociology at the University of Texas at Austin and President-Elect of the Society for Research on Adolescence
- Jan Urbanski Director of Safe and Humane Schools in the Institute on Family & Neighborhood Life at Clemson University
- Rodger Dinwiddie Executive Director and CEO of Students Taking A Right Stand (STARS Nashville)
- Larry D. Rosen Professor Emeritus and Past Chair of the Psychology Department at California State University-Dominguez Hills and Author of the book "The Distracted Mind: Ancient Brains in a High-Tech World"
- Beth Rosenberg Director of Tech Kids Unlimited
- Brian Puerling Director of Education Technology at Catherine Cook School in Chicago and Author of Teaching in the Digital Age™ Series
- Phillippa Paisley Research and Public Education Coordinator at The Children’s Movement of Florida
- Andres S. Bustamante Postdoctoral Fellow at Temple University
- Maryann Harman Founder of Music with Mar., LLC
- Iheoma U. Iruka Director of Research & Evaluation at the Buffett Early Childhood Institute at University of Nebraska
- I no longer heard all her phone calls or knew who she was talking to.
- Not having a family landline changed my habit of “how to answer a phone politely.” “Harman residence. Gioia speaking. May I ask who’s calling?”
- Children will use a phone to disappear into their room.
- A cell phone should be given when child is around 12 and beginning to do activities with other children – i.e., movies, mall, birthday party. This is for safety and peace of mind / convenience for you.
- Children under 12 should always be with another parent; therefore, having a cell phone isn’t necessary as the parents should communicate directly – unless you want to get a possible series of phone calls about why “someone is not playing with me and I want to come home.”
- A child should always have a phone when they are a driver. Most cars today have hands free ability. Texting is serious and should be discussed at length. The feature can be life saving as proven in recent events. Turning off the feature could be dangerous. Therefore, we can only hope our voices are deep in their head when we’re not there.
- Having a phone comes with responsibility. Losing or breaking a phone would mean not having a phone and not being able to go places where you require them having one until it is replaced. The lost/ broken phone should be replaced by the child with you setting the options of how that can be done – chores, allowance.
- It should be a basic phone for calls only. As the child ages, features can be added.
Highlights:
- “If the question were whether teens should have cell phones, I would answer yes in most circumstances. However, children are receiving cell phones at younger and younger ages, and I am not a fan of elementary school children owning cell phones. While there is not a magic age or a one-size-fits-all for when a child is ready for a cell phone, there is often little reason to rush toward ownership. While children may very well need access to technology at school, there are a variety of devices (tablets, for example) that can allow internet access without opening a young child up to the continued distraction and pressure to be ‘always available,’ which is what cell phone ownership often demands.”
Patti Agatston // President, International Bullying Prevention Association & Co-author, “Cyber Bullying: Bullying in the Digital Age”
- "To answer this question, I consulted a 16-year-old who uses her phone extensively for texting and social media. I expected a resounding “yes” from her, but her first reaction was “No, it’s too distracting and addictive.” But then she began to think of the positive uses – ability to reach parents easily, consulting with friends about homework, etc. - and she concluded that it’s a complicated question. I agree. The answer varies by the age of children and their needs."
Joan W. Almon // Co-founder and Director of Programs, Alliance for Childhood
- "It depends on a multitude of factors. For example, how old is the child? A two-year-old does not need a cell phone, but a six-year-old might. So now ask yourself why does the child need a phone? If s/he is a child that is left alone often either at home or at series of scheduled practices/events, having such a tool can be quite handy for the family as well as make everyone feel safe. If having a phone is simply a fashion, social, or economic statement, I would say no."
Christopher P. Brown // Professor of Education, University of Texas at Austin
< >- Elizabeth K. Englander Director of the Massachusetts Aggression Reduction Center and Professor of Psychology at Bridgewater State University
- Eric S. Swanson Assistant Professor of Theoretical Nuclear Physics at University of Pittsburgh
- Tamara Kaldor Assistant Director for the Technology in Early Childhood Center at Erikson Institute
- Christopher P. Brown Professor in the College of Education at the University of Texas at Austin
- Faith Rogow Maven of Media Literacy Education at InsightersEducation.com
- Joan W. Almon Co-founder and Director of Programs at Alliance for Childhood
- Tarajean Yazzie-Mintz Co-Director of the Office of Research & Sponsored Programs and Senior Program Officer of TCU ECE Initiatives at American Indian College
- Why do you think your child is or isn’t ready for a smartphone?
- What would be positive aspects of your child having a smartphone? What concerns do you have about your child owning one?
- Can your child have a phone conversation with you and communicate responsibly and consistently using text messaging?
- Do you think your child can take care of the phone, know when to put it away, and know when silence the ringer and other alert sounds?
- How would you respond if your child doesn’t answer your call or text message?
- Will the phone have a data plan? Does your child understand how data plans work?
- Who will be in control of internet access and what apps are installed?
- Will you have all your child’s passwords?
- Will location settings be enabled on apps and the phone? Why or why not?
- What social media apps and games is your child interested in? Have you looked at them together? What do you each like and dislike about them?
- Does your child understand cyberbullying and online harassment and how to handle an uncomfortable digital situation? Do you?
- What should your child do in an emergency?
- What hours will your child not be allowed to use their phone and where it will be stored during “off hours”?
- monitor activities,
- set and enforce clear rules,
- model the phone-related behavior that you expect of your kids, and
- engage kids in ongoing conversations about what they do with their phone,
- A phone is sort of like a pet – there are ongoing responsibilities that accompany the benefits. If you are still worried about your child losing their mittens, then they probably aren’t mature enough to keep track of a phone.
- Just because a kid wants a phone doesn’t mean they actually need one. Invite them to make their best case to you. The ensuing conversation should give you a chance to make sure that what you expect your child to do with their phone and what they expect to do with it are the same.
- Phones and their various functions are an ongoing expense. If your child isn’t willing to shoulder part of the financial cost, even in a token way, then the gift might be premature.
- Cyber safety is a must. You wouldn’t hand over the car keys to a child who had never demonstrated that they could drive. Likewise, before letting your kid walk out of the house with their own phone, check that they know:
- your rules and the consequences for breaking them
- basic etiquette about getting people’s permission to take or share photos
- how to keep their information private (except from you, of course!)
- how to spot misleading marketing techniques, e.g., in app purchases, pop-up ads, clickbait, and scam phone calls
- what to do / where to find support if they are cyberbullied or friended by strangers who get a bit too “friendly”
- the automatic, no negotiation deal breakers: The phone is taken away if they use it in ways that might harm themselves or others (e.g., texting and driving, sexting, cyberbullying, disrupting school classes, not getting enough sleep because they’re staying up at night to use the phone, etc.).
Image: g-stockstudio / iStock.
from Wallet HubWallet Hub
via Finance Xpress
0 comments